Why Arne Slot is right and wrong about the VAR pattern against Liverpool

Why Arne Slot is right and wrong about the VAR pattern against Liverpool

Arne Slot is finally letting the mask slip, and it’s about time. After months of maintaining a calm, Dutch composure while Liverpool’s Champions League hopes flickered, the 3-2 defeat at Old Trafford on Sunday pushed him over the edge. He didn't just complain about a single decision; he alleged a "complete pattern" of VAR working against his side.

It’s easy to dismiss a manager’s post-match rant as deflective theater. We’ve seen it from Mourinho, Klopp, and Ferguson for decades. But Slot’s "VAR fury" isn't just about a suspected Benjamin Sesko handball or a missed penalty. It’s the sound of a manager realizing that his tactical overhaul is being undermined by a combination of officiating inconsistency and a recurring soft center in his own squad.

If you're a Liverpool fan, you're likely nodding along with him. If you're a rival, you're calling it sour grapes. The reality, as is usually the case, sits uncomfortably in the middle.

The Old Trafford flashpoint and the Sesko goal

The specific moment that ignited this fire was Benjamin Sesko’s goal. Slot pointed out the "curve of the ball" changing—a classic indicator of a handball that VAR seemingly ignored. But the frustration goes deeper than one touch. Slot referenced a previous encounter where play wasn't stopped for a Liverpool player needing five stitches, yet was halted for a United injury later on.

He’s highlighting a lack of standard application. When the refereeing feels like a "coin flip," as some analysts have noted this season, it erodes the tactical foundation a manager tries to build. If you can't rely on the rules being applied the same way twice, how do you coach a "rest defense" or a high line?

But here’s the rub: Slot himself admitted the second goal wasn't just a VAR failure. Liverpool lost the ball in a "stupid position." You can’t blame the man in the van at Stockley Park for a lack of concentration in your own half.

A tactical shift that left the door ajar

The transition from Jürgen Klopp’s "heavy metal football" to Slot’s more controlled, selective pressing was supposed to make Liverpool more robust. On paper, the data from the 2024/25 season suggested it worked. The expected goals against (xGA) dropped significantly. They were harder to break down.

However, the 2025/26 campaign has told a different story. The "selective press" has often looked more like a "passive block."

  • Pressing volume is down: Liverpool's pressed sequences have plummeted compared to the Klopp era.
  • Duel success is failing: The team is winning fewer than 50% of their physical battles on the ground.
  • Inconsistency in transitions: Without the constant energy of the previous regime, Liverpool look exposed when their initial structure is bypassed.

Slot’s tactics require 100% buy-in and 100% fitness. When injuries hit—like the current concerns surrounding Mo Salah—the system's flaws are magnified. Opponents have realized that if they can weather the initial slow-build, Liverpool's current iteration doesn't have the same "fear factor" in recovery that they once did.

Why the VAR obsession is a dangerous game

It’s a pattern, sure. Every manager in the Premier League has a list of 20 "indefensible" decisions that cost them points. But focusing on the officials is a double-edged sword. It validates the players' feeling of being "wronged," which can sometimes paper over the "gaping canyons" in performance.

Liverpool are currently fighting for a top-five finish to secure Champions League football. They have Chelsea, Aston Villa, and Brentford left on the calendar. If the narrative in the dressing room is that "the world is against us," it might provide a temporary siege mentality. But it won't fix the fact that they are conceding "ridiculous goals" because of individual errors.

You can't control the VAR monitor. You can control how many times you give the ball away in your own third.

How Liverpool fixes this before the season ends

Complaining to the media is part of the job, but the work on the training pitch is where the top-five spot will be won. Slot needs to find a way to inject intensity back into a midfield that has looked leggy in the second half of matches.

Tighten the rest defense

The "pattern" Slot should be most worried about isn't VAR; it's the ease with which teams are scoring late winners like Kobbie Mainoo's. This comes down to the positioning of the full-backs and the holding midfielder during the attacking phase. They are getting caught between two stools—neither fully committing to the attack nor fully prepared for the counter.

Forget the officials

The most successful teams act as if VAR doesn't exist. If you play well enough to win by two or three goals, a single bad VAR call becomes a footnote rather than a season-defining tragedy. Slot needs his players to stop looking at the referee and start looking at their markers.

Use the anger

If Slot can channel this "fury" into a more aggressive defensive display against Chelsea and Villa, it might actually serve a purpose. Liverpool are at their best when they play with a chip on their shoulder. They just need to make sure that chip doesn't turn into a permanent excuse for underachievement.

The hunt for Champions League football is still in their hands. It's time to stop talking about the "curve of the ball" and start focusing on the curve of their season. If they don't, the only pattern people will remember is a promising start that fizzled out into mid-table frustration.

Stop waiting for the VAR apology. Start winning the duels. It's that simple.

DP

Diego Perez

With expertise spanning multiple beats, Diego Perez brings a multidisciplinary perspective to every story, enriching coverage with context and nuance.