Why Rick Caruso Clinging to Karen Bass Proves the Los Angeles Political Establishment Is Broke

Why Rick Caruso Clinging to Karen Bass Proves the Los Angeles Political Establishment Is Broke

Billionaire developer Rick Caruso dropped over $100 million of his own fortune in 2022 trying to convince Los Angeles that incumbent leadership was destroying the city. Fast forward to the close of the 2026 mayoral cycle, and Caruso found himself holding a microphone to announce he was voting for Karen Bass—the very mayor he tried to oust.

The mainstream political commentary treated this like a high-minded moment of civic unity or a principled stance against progressive challenger Nithya Raman.

It was neither. It was a textbook display of elite self-preservation.

When a billionaire developer and a entrenched machine politician join forces, it is not because the city’s governance is working. It is because the establishment is terrified of structural accountability.

The Myth of the "Safe Incumbent"

The traditional media narrative frames Caruso’s decision as a reasonable reaction to "extreme" proposals, specifically Raman’s critiques of the LAPD leadership and municipal spending.

Let's dissect that logic.

For four years, business leaders, neighborhood councils, and working-class Angelenos watched City Hall navigate homelessness, housing affordability, and public safety with incrementalism. Caruso built his entire political brand on calling out that inertia. Yet, when presented with a choice between an incumbent whose administration delivered incremental metrics and a challenger offering structural urban planning fixes, Caruso retreated directly into the arms of the establishment.

Why? Because predictable stagnation is profitable for the real estate machine. Rapid, data-driven systemic reform is not.

When political commentators bemoan progressive proposals as "experimental," they ignore the reality that the status quo is itself a failed experiment. Continuing to dump billions into legacy municipal structures while expecting different results is not conservatism or pragmatic realism. It is institutional laziness.

ESTABLISHMENT VS. REFORM: THE LA CITY HALL PLAYBOOK

[ Legacy Machine Politics ]              [ Structural Urban Reform ]
• Incremental housing quotas            • Transit-oriented zoning deregulation
• Preservation of bureaucracy           • Elimination of administrative delays
• High-friction permitting processes    • High-density housing mandates
• Backroom political coalitions         • Transparent municipal metrics

The Real Reason Business Elites Fear Urban Planners

Nithya Raman came to City Hall with a background in urban planning from MIT. That detail makes political insiders deeply uncomfortable.

In major metropolitan centers, land use, zoning, and municipal contracting form the primary currency of power. Under the legacy system, getting anything built in Los Angeles requires endless discretionary approvals, environmental review friction, and backroom negotiations. That environment favors titan developers who can afford years of bureaucratic delay and political lobbying.

An urban planner who understands code, density, and systemic permitting reform threatens that entire racket.

When a politician promises to strip away the discretionary power of City Hall and implement transparent, streamlined rules for housing and transit, the value of elite political access plummets. Caruso’s "extreme concern" was never about public safety or municipal stability. It was about protecting a system where access to power dictates who gets to build.

The "Public Safety" Smoke Screen

Caruso and Bass both weaponized public safety arguments against Raman, focusing on LAPD staffing and leadership.

The argument goes like this: if you vote against unchecked police budget increases or ask hard questions about public safety ROI, you are "anti-safety".

This is a complete false choice.

I have watched major cities incinerate tax dollars on emergency response while ignoring the fundamental urban infrastructure that prevents crime in the first place—adequate street lighting, fast emergency medical response, active commercial corridors, and housing stability.

Evaluating a police chief’s performance or questioning budget allocation isn't "risky experimentation". It is standard fiduciary management. Treating municipal departments as sacred cows immune to performance audits is how cities end up broke with declining services.

What Real Civic Leadership Requires

The coalition between Caruso and Bass did not stop the tide; it merely exposed how out-of-touch the legacy political establishment had become. Voters chose structural change over defensive endorsement pacts because the math on the status quo no longer adds up.

If Los Angeles wants to solve its core crises, it has to break the habits of its political class:

  • Stop confusing longevity with competence. An incumbent holding together a fragile coalition of legacy interest groups is not providing stability; they are managing decay.
  • Audit outcomes, not intentions. A budget increase is an input, not an output. Demand clear, audited metrics for every dollar spent on housing and public safety.
  • End discretionary real estate politics. Streamline zoning and permitting so that building housing does not require a political team and a war chest.

The media framed Caruso’s refusal to back Raman—and his ultimate vote for Bass—as a dramatic twist. In reality, it was the most predictable move a defender of the status quo could make.

The political establishment joined hands to protect the machine. The voters looked at the machine and decided it was time to tear it down.

DG

Daniel Green

Drawing on years of industry experience, Daniel Green provides thoughtful commentary and well-sourced reporting on the issues that shape our world.