Why Xi Jinping Viewing the US Constitution Is Not the Irony You Think It Is

Why Xi Jinping Viewing the US Constitution Is Not the Irony You Think It Is

When Chinese President Xi Jinping concluded a high-stakes visit to Washington by viewing the original U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights at the National Archives, Western media commentary largely defaulted to a predictable script. According to mainstream political observers and press reports covering the event, the photo opportunity was framed as a moment of rich, almost theatrical irony—the leader of an authoritarian, one-party state standing before the foundational charters of American liberal democracy and individual rights.

That interpretation, while intuitively appealing to Western audiences, misses the fundamental reality of how Beijing views constitutionalism, state power, and its own governance model. To view Xi’s stop at the National Archives merely as an awkward contradiction is to misunderstand both Chinese political philosophy and the strategic messaging behind state diplomacy.

Two Completely Different Definitions of a Constitution

The core misunderstanding in typical coverage stems from assuming that the word "constitution" carries the same functional meaning in Washington and Beijing.

In the American tradition, rooted in Enlightenment philosophy and the writings of James Madison and Alexander Hamilton, a constitution is primarily a limiting document. Its central purpose is to restrain the power of the state, divide authority across competing branches, and carve out a sphere of inalienable rights—such as freedom of speech, religion, and due process—that the government cannot infringe upon. The Bill of Rights exists explicitly to protect the individual from the state.

In the People's Republic of China, however, constitutional theory operates on an entirely different premise. According to scholars of Chinese law and political science, China’s constitution—most recently revised in 2018—is not designed to constrain the ruling party or establish an independent judiciary capable of overriding state policy. Instead, it is an enabling and programmatic document. It codifies the leadership of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), outlines the ideological direction of the state, and organizes administrative authority to achieve national development and social stability.

When Western commentators point out the contrast between the First Amendment and China's strict media and internet controls, they are highlighting a divergence that Beijing neither hides nor views as a flaw. From the perspective of CCP theorists, the American system's emphasis on individual rights and institutional checks often leads to political gridlock, polarization, and an inability to execute long-term national projects. Conversely, Beijing promotes its model of "whole-process people's democracy" and "law-based governance" as a superior mechanism for delivering material prosperity and collective order.

The Optics of Respect vs. Ideological Endorsement

Diplomatic protocols during state visits are meticulously choreographed. According to diplomatic historians and former State Department officials, stops at cultural and historical landmarks—whether the Great Wall in Beijing or the National Archives in Washington—serve a specific function in international relations: signaling mutual respect for a host nation's heritage without endorsing its political system.

When U.S. presidents visit Beijing and tour the Forbidden City, they are not expressing admiration for imperial autocracy. They are acknowledging the longevity and cultural weight of Chinese civilization. Similarly, when Xi Jinping views the Charters of Freedom, the gesture is aimed at recognizing the historical foundation of the United States as a major global power.

Furthermore, such visits carry significant domestic messaging value for a Chinese leader. State media in China frequently portrays the country as an equal partner to the United States, capable of engaging with American history and institutions from a position of confidence rather than deference. Viewing the founding documents of the world's other superpower reinforces the narrative of "major-country diplomacy"—the idea that Beijing stands on equal footing with Washington and engages with its traditions on its own terms.

What Mainstream Commentary Overlooks About Governance

By focusing exclusively on the superficial irony of the moment, standard media narratives overlook the deeper ideological competition underway between the two nations.

  1. The Debate Over Legitimacy: In the United States, political legitimacy is derived from procedural democracy—free and fair elections, constitutional adherence, and the protection of minority rights. In China, the CCP bases its legitimacy largely on performance—economic growth, poverty alleviation, technological advancement, and national rejuvenation. Neither side accepts the other's metric as the sole valid standard.
  2. The Role of Law: Western observers often equate the "rule of law" with constitutionalism and judicial independence. In Chinese political discourse, the concept is closer to "rule by law," where legal frameworks are strengthened to improve administrative efficiency, curb local corruption, and create a predictable environment for commerce, while remaining firmly under the overarching authority of the Party.
  3. Historical Continuity: Both nations view their founding documents and historical trajectories as sources of exceptionalism. Understanding how Beijing interprets American history requires recognizing that Chinese strategists study the U.S. Constitution not as a blueprint to copy, but as an artifact that explains how the United States built and maintained its power—and where its internal vulnerabilities might lie.

Moving Beyond Surface-Level Analysis

To accurately assess U.S.-China relations, observers have to look past the easy framing of diplomatic photo-ops. Treating a visit to the National Archives as a simple clash between democracy and authoritarianism reduces complex geopolitical dynamics to a caricature.

A more rigorous approach requires examining how each government actually uses its foundational texts to justify power, manage internal dissent, and project influence abroad. Only by understanding the distinct legal and philosophical frameworks driving both Washington and Beijing can analysts make sense of where the two powers can cooperate, where they will inevitably clash, and what each side is truly signaling when they stand before history.

AW

Aiden Williams

Aiden Williams approaches each story with intellectual curiosity and a commitment to fairness, earning the trust of readers and sources alike.